An analysis to distinguish if the mind is distinct from the body

Sixth Meditation, Part 1: Cartesian body Summary The Sixth and final Meditation is entitled "The existence of material things, and the real distinction between mind and body," and it opens with the Meditator considering the existence of material things.

An analysis to distinguish if the mind is distinct from the body

Find articles by Sunil K. Deshmukh Marg, Mumbai, This article has been cited by other articles in PMC. Abstract Treatment of diseases of the brain by drugs or surgery necessitates an understanding of its structure and functions.

The philosophical neurosurgeon soon encounters difficulties when localising the abstract concepts of mind and soul within the tangible gram organ containing billion neurones. Hippocrates had focused attention on the brain as the seat of the mind. Experiences gained from accidental injuries Phineas Gage or temporal lobe resection William Beecher Scoville ; studies on how we see and hear and more recent data from functional magnetic resonance studies have made us aware of the extensive network of neurones in the cerebral hemispheres that subserve the functions of the mind.

The soul or atman, credited with the ability to enliven the body, was located by ancient anatomists and philosophers in the lungs or heart, in the pineal gland Descartesand generally in the brain. When the deeper parts of the brain came within the reach of neurosurgeons, the brainstem proved exceptionally delicate and vulnerable.

If there be a soul in each of us, surely, it is enshrined here. Brain, Brainstem, Mind, Soul, Neurology, Neurosurgery, Philosophy Introduction Millennia ago, we embarked on a quest for knowledge of the wonderful structure of man.

The organ that puzzled earlier observers most was the human brain. Despite our many explorations, we remained in awe of this organ. We are now aware of nerve cells, their connections and their modes of communication amongst themselves and with a variety of other structures.

Injury to, and disease in, the brain often provides crucial insights on the role of its different parts. A dramatic example is the injury suffered by American railway foreman, Phineas Gage in Before his accident, Gage was liked by friends and acquaintances who considered him to be honest, trustworthy, hard working and dependable.

A freak accident caused a metal tamping rod to enter under his left zygomatic arch and exit through the top of his skull Barker, The accident left him with little if any intellectual impairment but after the accident, Gage became vulgar, irresponsible, capricious and prone to profanity.

The company that had previously regarded him as the most efficient and capable of their employees dismissed him from his job.

SparkNotes: Meditations on First Philosophy: Sixth Meditation, Part 1: Cartesian body

His change in character after the accident made this the index case for personality change due to frontal lobe damage. Subsequent studies See, for example, Blumer and Benson, have shown a wide spectrum of abnormal behaviour compulsive and explosive actions, lack of inhibition, unwarranted maniacal suspicion and alcohol and drug abuse after injuries to and disease in the frontal or temporal lobes and their pathways to the deeper regions of the brain.

Similar abnormalities also follow chemical derangements in the brain. Modern marvels such as computerised tomography and magnetic resonance imaging of the nervous system have provided significant additional data. Functional magnetic resonance imaging now allows us to further localise function within the structure of the brain and correlate abnormalities of its structure and function.

Even so, two entities remain enigmatic: Where are they located? Do they lie within the brain? Since neurophysicians treat patients with a wide variety of abnormalities of the brain and neurosurgeons lay bare the brain and often work in its interior, can they provide insights?

Neurologists and neurosurgeons rank high among scientists participating in philosophical debates about what might extend beyond the physical world. They are constantly dealing with patients who have fallen into the deep hole of unconsciousness.

In their attempts at restoring normalcy to bodies and minds, they also grapple with life and death. Inevitably, they ponder spirituality and the dominion of the soul. The Mind We are embodied spirits and inspirited bodies, or, if you will, embodied minds and minded bodies. The term is often used to refer, by implication, to the thought processes of reason.

This changed with the works of Hippocrates ca. On the sacred disease. In his book De anima On the soulAristotle BC— BC felt that man is born with a blank slate tabula rasa on which experiences and perceptions are written to form the mind. Although tabula rasa is a concept traditionally attributed to Locke, Aristotle first referred to it.

What it thinks must be in it just as characters may be said to be on a writing tablet on which as yet nothing actually stands written:In the selection from the Meditations on First Philosophy that we read, Descartes argues that the mind is something distinct from any body.

But the Meditations begins with a discussion of a topic seemingly far removed from the nature of the mind: the question of whether we .

Evaluate the argument that Descartes makes based on clear and distinct perception for the distinction between mind and body In arguing for the distinction between mind and body, Descartes seeks to show that the two are . René Descartes: The Mind-Body Distinction.

One of the deepest and most lasting legacies of Descartes’ philosophy is his thesis that mind and body are really distinct—a thesis now called "mind-body dualism." He reaches this conclusion by arguing that the nature of the mind (that is, a thinking, non-extended thing) is completely different from that of the body (that is, an extended, non-thinking thing), and therefore it .

A summary of Sixth Meditation, Part 1: Cartesian body in Rene Descartes's Meditations on First Philosophy. Learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of Meditations on First Philosophy and what it means.

and the real distinction between mind and body," and it opens with the Meditator considering the existence of material. extension. So the ideas of mind and body show that minds and bodies are completely distinct. So in creating minds, God would not need to create bodies; and in creating bodies, God would not need to create minds.

An analysis to distinguish if the mind is distinct from the body

This shows that they can exist separately, i.e. that mind and body are two distinct substances. Analysis of Descartes’ Mind/Body Distinction Essay - In his Meditations on First Philosophy, Descartes states “I have a clear and distinct idea of myself, in as far as I am only a thinking and unextended thing, and as, on the other hand, I possess a distinct idea of body, in as far as it is only an extended and unthinking thing”.


SparkNotes: Principles of Philosophy: I– Mind Body Dualism