Ultimately, it is inevitable that context plays a significant role in changing female and male representations due to the impact it has on story patterns. Directed by Joel Coen. Produced by Joel Coen and Ethan Coen. The Odyssey utilises male protagonists to make a commentary traditional values of focalizing a member of the aristocracy position, whilst O Brother, Where Art Thou?
One important point is that in the citations for the film, the time on the DVD version of the movie is given. In other words, if you go to that particular point on the DVD, you can see what is being discussed. As long as humans have gathered together, they have told stories.
One of the archetypes of storytelling is that of the lost soul, struggling to find his or her way home. Tumultuous experiences, terrible odds, and horrifying foes confront the protagonist, who must overcome them all, in order to successfully complete the journey.
Since this work was originally penned nearly three thousand years ago, many others have taken up the story and use it as a foundation for new renditions. Both versions show the protagonist struggling to reach home in order to save his family. Both allow for supernatural elements to oppose, or at times to support, the hero on his journey.
In essence, this story serves as a case study for what Robert Stam refers to as fidelity between film and novel or written work. What does it mean to take a piece of literature and put it onto film?
Is it appropriate for the filmmaker to make changes, or must he or she tell the story exactly as written? While there are elements of storytelling that transcend the medium, there are many that do not, and therefore each medium must stand on its own merits. Therefore, it is appropriate to consider the elements that are inherent in film and novel, and how those can, or cannot, be transferred from one to the other.
Using examples from both stories, the method of storytelling, and the benefits and advantages of each can be made evident. Story Summary and Organization Both versions tell of a man, Odysseus in the written work and Ulysses Everett McGill called Everett in the filmwho finds himself in dire straits for an extended period of time, fighting to return to his wife and child ren.
Companions share these experiences, some for long periods of time and others briefly, yet the protagonists focus on their ultimate goals, rather than on the needs or cares of the companions. Adversaries are placed before them, some more dangerous than others, and all are overcome.
Eventually, the hero in each story finds himself returned to his loved ones, a wiser and more dedicated family man. While the basic story can be reduced to a few sentences, Homer utilized over 12, metered lines to flesh out the story, while the Coen Brothers used approximately an hour and forty-five minutes of screen time.
The details that make up the bulk of each work demonstrate the similarities and differences in structure, focus, and storytelling approach. Both film and epic poem use a similar structure; there is much parallel editing.
Obviously, as the details of the story are changed so much, there are differences in what is taking place, but the manner in which the stories are organized is very similar. The scene itself is not presented in real time, but is retold after the fact, such as his account of Polyphemus in Book IX.
Likewise, there are sections when the story focuses upon Odysseus and others where Telemachos or Athena is the focal character. In this way, a form of parallel editing is utilized in the story. The film uses these same characteristics. For the majority of the film, it is assumed that Everett is leading his companions to a financial windfall, but in the end, he must admit to them that he received a letter from his ex-wife, who will soon marry another, prompting his escape plan.O Brother Where Art Thou- Everett doesn't want Pete's or Delmar's help.
The Odyssey is set in Ancient Greece. O Brother where Art Thou is set in the 's. Death People die in the Odyssey. No one dies in O Brother Where Art Thou. Crew Odysseus has an Army for a crew. Everett has two people he met in jail and a random guy they picked up on the road.
Characters The Odyssey has gods and goddesses in it. Another significant parallel between The Odyssey and O Brother, Where Art Thou? is the mystical call of the Sirens and the powers of the goddess Circe.
This parallel is the strongest element of comparison because it is very similar how each story describes the Sirens. O, Brother is on the left hand side; Odyssey on the right.
Learn with flashcards, games, and more — for free. The Odyssey compared to O Brother, Where Art Thou? Introduction The Odyssey, is an epic poem by Homer written based off of a true hero's journey back home. It's very loosely based on The Odyssey. The main characters are both somewhat similar - they both have a roguish trickster quality, and are both plagued by their own vanity.
Nov 27, · By Amanda Sarsha Video Sources: O Brother Where Art Thou, written and directed by the Coen brothers Photo Sources: Google Images.